Top-Tier School or Not?

October 19th, 2006 | Education
  • As Carol Hymowitz wrote, getting to the corner office has more to do with leadership talent and a drive for success than it does with having degree from a prestigious university.
  • Most CEOs of the biggest corporations didn’t attend Ivy League or other highly selective colleges. They went to state universities or to less-known private colleges.
  • Companies seeking to fill CEO and other senior jobs rarely consider candidates’ degrees. It’s what you’ve accomplished that matters, not what you were doing at 21.
  • A lot of people who earn degrees from tier-one schools usually aren’t willing to start at the bottom of a huge company and spend years scaling layers of management and hoping to reach the top.
  • A friend of mine had the pleasure of having a lot of high profile visitors come to his campus. One of them was the CEO of Enron and another one was the CFO of Tyco. These two specific individuals were in fact Harvard Business School graduates.

We know that sometimes parents and their college-bound children believe admission to a top-tier school with a powerful alumni network is a prerequisite to success in the upper echelons of business management.

It also has come to our attention that top-tier schools are embarrassed about the behavior of some of their graduates. They knew they had a problem with at best thing associated with unethical leaders and at worst being associated with criminals. They may not be able to 100% control their graduates.

Personally, I don’t really care where someone went to school. What counts most is his/her capacity to seize opportunities. I like to see students who recall immersing themselves in their interests, contributing actively to extracurricular activities, becoming campus leaders, and forging strong relationships with their teachers.

As you might already know, Bill Gates quit Harvard to start Microsoft. Michael Dell quit the University of Texas-Austin to start his own company: Dell Computer. Steve Jobs also quit Reed College in Portland, Oregon, to work at Atari for a while and then found Apple Computer. None of them ever returned to college to pursue a formal degree. They found that their classroom studies less compelling than their own ideas.

Warren Buffett also didn’t even want to go to college. Although he enrolled at the Wharton School-University of Pennsylvania, he did it at his father’s behest. He stayed there for only two years, then returned home and graduated from Nebraska a year later.

By then, he was devouring the books by David Dodd and Benjamin Graham, who advocated investing in companies that had “intrinsic business value“–a view that became his guiding investment principal. When he learned the two men were teaching at Columbia University’s business school, he wrote to them to ask if he could attend their lectures. He then earned a master’s degree in economics at Columbia in 1951. But he didn’t go there for a degree. He went for those two teachers, who were already becomes his heroes.

I’m not going to tell you that going to the top-tier schools is useless.

I’m not going to tell you to quit your school and start your own business right now.

Going to the top-tier schools will give you unforgettable experiences and access to the top professors as well as prestigious alumni networks. It will also help you to get a better job and bring you a lot of money into your pocket as soon as you’ve graduated.

On the other side, starting your own company, as Steve Jobs said, “is the best decisions I ever made.” However, it’s the exceptionally inventive person who can do this. If you have a big, big new idea, you can get venture financing–and if you wait to graduate someone else may capitalize on your idea first.

So, should I go to the top-tier schools or should I start my own business now?

As Steve Jobs said in a graduation speech at Stanford last year, like any life decision, is up to each individual. “You have to trust your gut,” he said.

Possibly Related:

Trackbacks/Pings

  1. Pendidikan di Indonesia « Gojekkere’s Weblog
  2. Pendidikan Indonesia Terbaik di Dunia? » Nofie Iman
  3. My Blog » Blog Archive » pendidikan di indonesia
  4. Pendidikan di Indonesia « LPP Community!
  5. Pendidikan di Indonesia « Ic44’s Blog
  6. Lia2009’s Blog
  7. Pendidikan Di Indonesia « Icha4393’s Blog
  8. Comments

  9. kus

    maaf , berhubungan langsung atau tidak dengan article pokoke taqaballahu minna wa minkum ye :D

    minal aidzin wal faidzin mohon maaf lahir dan batin :D

  10. Charlie

    well…it’s always difficult to take any decision. i wrote an entry about this on my blog:roll:

  11. Oskar Syahbana

    I think you’re right but not completely at it. Ivy league degree might not be needed to become successful, but is sure will gain you boost over your peers. I mean come on, when a company is having two people with the same GPA, one is from a less-known university, and the other one is from Harvard, I believe they will go with the later.

    And being from Ivy league also helps if you wanted to be an Entrepreneur. Simply because beautiful mind thinks alike, Ivy league graduates can gain easier access to a vast network.

    But again, Ivy league is not a prerequisite to become successful, it will only give you a head-start advantage :-)

  12. Gustaf Sorman Nilsson

    I think your comments regarding Ivy League is very interesting. Reading ‘The Millionaire Next Door’ confirms your ideas.

    A large share of millionaires in the US are not educated at Ivy League Universities and most of them do not have educated professions. I find this interesting, it suggests that in many cases it is not your socio-economic background or your education that determines your success. Rather it is your purpose and your strive to succeed that in the end will determine how you live your life.

    More on the thoughts regarding purposeful living and generation Y can be found on http://www.thinque.com.au/blog

  13. James

    Hmmm an interesting article. Some of the people graduating from top-tier schools including Ivy league schools like Harvard, Yale and etc are so irresponsible and pathetic that makes me wonder how that is even possible. I personally attended for my undergraduate degree at a somewhat less known and less prestigious school and still managed to join a top-tier school for my higher degrees (PhD & M.D.). The determining factors to those were my MCAT score and my GRE score plus the research experiences that I had accumulated over the four years as an undergraduate. The bottom line here is that no matter where one is enrolled or what type of school, one can still become the best of the best and be the top in his/her field. Ivy league and top tier schools are playgrounds for rich kids and not for the hardworking individuals.

  14. Dean

    My top picks so far:
    HBS MBA http://www.hbs.edu/mba/
    UCLA MBA http://www.anderson.ucla.edu/x47.xml
    NYU MBA w4.stern.nyu.edu/admissions/
    Emory MBA http://www.goizueta.emory.edu/degree/fulltimemba/
    Terry UGA MBA mba.terry.uga.edu
    Princeton MSF http://www.princeton.edu/~bcf/master.htm
    INSEAD MBA http://www.insead.edu/mba/ 2nd 21May/1st 1Oct
    RSM MFM http://www.ecft.nl/mfm
    Oxford MBA http://www.sbs.ox.ac.uk

    http://www.mgmt.purdue.edu/programs/masters/Degree_Programs/Full_Time/MSF/home.asp
    http://www.mgmt.purdue.edu/programs/masters/degree_programs/msfprogram.asp

    http://www.marshall.usc.edu/leventhal/curriculum/macc/master-of-accounting-overview.htm

  15. Ralph Harriman

    Your prejudices preclude your predisposition towards hierarchical tendencies of population groups. Your attitude defies biology. You insensitivity and dysfunctionality displays crass judgement and I allege it is because you have come from a caste society where rank and privilege disgust you.

    I come from a generational family where tradition and class do matter. Perhaps this egalitarian attitude may be inclined to trump advantage but I bet the farm that base of the pyramid will remain the base it is.

    Life aspires to greatness, rank and privilege. We marry and sire children with the best that we can find. To deny this is to deny self. Such self-loathing is destestable and betrays risk adverse strategies.

Looking forward to hear your thoughts.